Balasore Train Crash: Urgent Need for Maintenance and Safety Upgrades
Balasore Train Crash: Urgent Need for Maintenance and Safety Upgrades
Natalie Johnson
Posted 06/21/2023
A recent train crash in Balasore, India has resulted in hundreds of casualties and injuries, highlighting the critical need to ensure robust maintenance practices and safety measures are in place. While the investigation is still underway, the Ministry of Railways has identified the root cause of the incident and made recommendations to prevent future accidents.
The tragic collision occurred in Balasore, Odisha injuring over 1,200 people and claiming 292 lives thus far. Three trains were involved in the accident: the Bengaluru-Howrah Superfast Express, the Coromandel Express, and a freight train.
The root cause of the incident was determined to be improper changes to the electronic point machine. This machine operates turnouts, allowing a train to be directed from one track to another via point blades. The electronic interlocking system is meant to ensure conflicting signals are not sent to multiple trains. A signal failure led to the Coromandel Express diverting to an occupied loop line and colliding with a freight train. The derailed cars then interfered with the last 2 cars of the Bengaluru-Howrah Superfast Express. Seventeen coaches from the two passenger trains were derailed due to an improper change in the electronic interlocking system.
Courtesy of Frontline / The Hindu
There are many possible causes that led to this accident including human error, mechanical failure, and track defects. The Central Bureau of Investigation is performing an investigation to determine which errors were involved in this crash to implement corrective measures.
Among the factors contributing to the accident, maintenance-related issues have come to the forefront. Reports from the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) indicate ¾ of 217 train accidents occurring between 2017-2018 and 2020-2021 were caused by derailments, which are often linked to the inadequate maintenance of tracks. The decline in funds allocated for track renewal works and underutilization of available funds has exacerbated these maintenance challenges.
Recognizing the urgency to enhance safety, Indian Railways has taken action to address maintenance-related issues and prevent future accidents.
Anil Kumar Lahoti, the Railway Board Chairman, has directed general managers and senior engineers to prioritize interacting with their staff to address maintenance, safety-related issues, and daily monitoring. Encouraging such interaction will allow for more visibility as those on the front lines have first-hand knowledge of the strengths and weaknesses of assets in their jurisdiction. In addition, senior officials must inspect all aspects of maintenance and educate their employees on the correct and safe execution of work.
When field officials are deployed for maintenance activities on the railways, they must only be utilized for those activities and spend the maximum amount of time at work sites to ensure safety and reliability. These initiatives aim to ensure constant vigilance and timely resolution of maintenance concerns.
The key areas the railways must focus on were outlined by IRCTC News:
Infrastructure Maintenance: Regular inspections, maintenance, and repairs of tracks, signals, and bridges must occur promptly.
Utilization of Technology: Advanced technologies such as automatic braking systems, improved signaling systems, and condition monitoring systems can improve safety.
Training and Education: Continuous education programs for all staff (conductors, engineers, maintenance personnel) are essential to ensure they have the proper knowledge and skills to operate and maintain railways.
Safety and Public Awareness: The public must be educated about safety measures, emergency procedures, and responsible behavior while onboard to ensure their safety.
The Balasore train accident serves as a somber reminder of the ongoing challenges faced by Indian Railways. While the number of accidents per million train kilometers has decreased over the last decade, it is evident that additional efforts are needed to address maintenance issues, enhance existing infrastructure, and optimize staff resources.
Poor maintenance of tracks and overstretched staff are the two main problems Indian Railways must address. Following the accident, The Ministry of Railways is addressing maintenance-related issues, infrastructure improvements, technological advancements, comprehensive training programs, and stringent safety regulations in an effort to improve the safety and reliability of their railway network.
Midweek with Maintenance World
Looking for a midweek break? Keep up with the latest news brought to you every Wednesday by the Maintenance World crew.
The manufacturing industry is a crucial contributor to the economy, accounting for over 11% of the total output in the United States. However, many manufacturing companies are currently facing a skills gap, with more open job positions than there are workers ready to fill them. A study conducted by Deloitte and the Manufacturing Institute predicts that 2.1 million manufacturing positions will go unfilled by 2030, potentially leading to a loss of $1 trillion in GDP for the United States.
The manufacturing industry is a crucial contributor to the economy, accounting for over 11% of the total output in the United States. However, many manufacturing companies are currently facing a skills gap, with more open job positions than there are workers ready to fill them. A study conducted by Deloitte and the Manufacturing Institute predicts that 2.1 million manufacturing positions will go unfilled by 2030, potentially leading to a loss of $1 trillion in GDP for the United States.
Manufacturing has been a key component to the South Carolina economy in the last 10 years and the state's efforts to improve infrastructure and educate a highly skilled workforce are paying off. The state has been making headlines lately for its attractiveness to corporations around the world.
Manufacturing has been a key component to the South Carolina economy in the last 10 years and the state's efforts to improve infrastructure and educate a highly skilled workforce are paying off. The state has been making headlines lately for its attractiveness to corporations around the world.
The COVID-19 pandemic and recent world events have pushed manufacturing companies to shift their production to the United States in 2023, with 1,8000 companies in the US alone planning to reshore production to the states. While reshoring efforts are ramping up, manufacturers must be wary of the skills gap.
The COVID-19 pandemic and recent world events have pushed manufacturing companies to shift their production to the United States in 2023, with 1,8000 companies in the US alone planning to reshore production to the states. While reshoring efforts are ramping up, manufacturers must be wary of the skills gap.
Preventive Maintenance is as important as ever and this is extremely evident considering a radioactive capsule was lost in the vast landscape of Western Australia for nearly 2 weeks. Emergency services had been scanning the truck’s route for the last seven days and finally found the capsule on Wednesday, February 1st. A team driving down the road used radiation detection equipment to locate the capsule on the side of the road, outside of Newman.
Preventive Maintenance is as important as ever and this is extremely evident considering a radioactive capsule was lost in the vast landscape of Western Australia for nearly 2 weeks. Emergency services had been scanning the truck’s route for the last seven days and finally found the capsule on Wednesday, February 1st. A team driving down the road used radiation detection equipment to locate the capsule on the side of the road, outside of Newman.
It appears the three rail workers on board the train took the appropriate measure when the sensor alerted them a bearing/axel was too hot. However, upon conducting further research it appears the system of HBDs in North America are largely ineffective.
It appears the three rail workers on board the train took the appropriate measure when the sensor alerted them a bearing/axel was too hot. However, upon conducting further research it appears the system of HBDs in North America are largely ineffective.
After nearly 2 months of investigations and a root cause analysis, TC Energy Corp revealed the cause of the oil spill was likely a combination of a welding flaw and bending stress fatigue which resulted in a crack forming and eventually lead to the rupture. The cause of the bending stress is still unclear and remains a focal point of the root cause failure analysis a third-party is conducting.
After nearly 2 months of investigations and a root cause analysis, TC Energy Corp revealed the cause of the oil spill was likely a combination of a welding flaw and bending stress fatigue which resulted in a crack forming and eventually lead to the rupture. The cause of the bending stress is still unclear and remains a focal point of the root cause failure analysis a third-party is conducting.
On February 20th around 2pm an explosion erupted at the I. Schumann & Co. Foundry in Bedford, Ohio. The foundry recycles scrap metal into bronze and brass ingots and pellets. Fire officials say the cause of the explosion is under investigation by state and federal authorities but it appears the blast originated near a kettle-like piece of equipment which holds molten metals before being poured into molds.
On February 20th around 2pm an explosion erupted at the I. Schumann & Co. Foundry in Bedford, Ohio. The foundry recycles scrap metal into bronze and brass ingots and pellets. Fire officials say the cause of the explosion is under investigation by state and federal authorities but it appears the blast originated near a kettle-like piece of equipment which holds molten metals before being poured into molds.
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nullam rhoncus, odio eget elementum volutpat, enim risus vulputate mauris, et luctus augue massa et sapien. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. In efficitur mi in erat lacinia tincidunt. Cras vulputate nec nulla vitae pretium. Integer porttitor mattis justo at fringilla. Donec eleifend massa turpis, at auctor mi pulvinar sit amet. Cras ut turpis id arcu fringilla gravida.
