The Contract Maintenance Conundrum: Balancing Expertise and Cost

Paweł Bęś, Logistics and Maintenance Marketing Expert, QRmaint

Posted 8/7/2025

For many companies, the decision of how to handle maintenance is a complex one. While some choose to build and maintain their in-house teams, a significant number opt for contract maintenance. This approach is often the most efficient way to reduce the need for specialized knowledge and, perhaps most importantly, to cut costs.

However, the question of whether managed in-house maintenance or contract maintenance is superior is a persistent one, and both options present unique challenges. Administration, for instance, can be a minefield regardless of the chosen path. A maintenance agreement contract, for example, is a broad subject that can lead to numerous issues if not carefully drafted and agreed upon. This means that in-house maintenance isn’t always the straightforward solution it might seem to be.

Despite the complexities, contract maintenance remains a widespread practice. To put its scale into perspective, consider the aviation industry. There are over 4,000 FAA-certified repair stations across the United States, with roughly 80% of these being small to medium-sized businesses. These stations employ a staggering 255,000 Americans, including 188,000 technicians, dwarfing the approximately 30,000 airline mechanics employed directly by airlines. It highlights just how prevalent and vital contract maintenance is, even in highly regulated and specialized fields.

A critical tool for effectively managing both in-house and contract maintenance is a Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS). This article explores the intricacies of contract maintenance, highlighting its key advantages. We’ll also outline potential pitfalls and the critical factors companies should consider when outsourcing their maintenance needs. Considering our scope, we also discussed a particular focus on how a CMMS can be leveraged to optimize these processes.

What about contract maintenance models?

Traditional management contracts involve hiring a private company primarily for the satisfactory operation and routine maintenance of a utility, with investments typically excluded from their scope of work. Their payment structure normally combines a fixed fee with a performance-based component tied to Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), focusing on the efficient management of existing assets. This model provides a straightforward approach to outsourcing operational and basic maintenance tasks, requiring minimal capital expenditure from the private operator.

In contrast, a hybrid management and maintenance contract extends beyond simple operation and routine upkeep, aiming for ambitious service improvements, such as achieving 24/7 supply from intermittent sources, which necessitates substantial investments. This model uniquely blends elements of performance-based contracts and traditional design-bid-build approaches, integrating both capital and operational expenditures to balance costs and mitigate risks.

Leveraging digital tools in contract maintenance

In the context of contract maintenance, the implementation of a CMMS (Computerized Maintenance Management System), such as QRmaint CMMS in the ProFM facility management company, becomes crucial for effectively managing distributed infrastructure and technical teams. This system significantly streamlines facility management processes by providing a central source of data for facilities, eliminating informational chaos, and automating service request management, which is particularly important when handling over a hundred requests daily across multiple locations.

Thanks to the mobile application, field technicians have access to essential information in real-time, which, as Daniel Małysa, President of the Management Board at ProFM, emphasizes, saves 30 to 60 minutes on each inspection. Furthermore, CMMS enables the transition from reactive to preventive and predictive building maintenance through data collection and analysis, optimizing costs and improving communication with clients, ultimately enhancing the quality of services provided under contract agreements.

How CMMS Systems are Used in Contract Maintenance

A Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS) is an invaluable tool for companies engaging in contract maintenance, whether they are the client outsourcing the work or the service provider delivering it. It transforms the often complex and dispersed nature of outsourced maintenance into a streamlined, transparent, and data-driven process. Here’s how a CMMS can be effectively utilized in contract maintenance:

For the Client (Outsourcing Maintenance)

Centralized Asset and Contract Information: A CMMS acts as a single source of truth for all assets under contract. Clients can store detailed information about each asset (e.g., serial numbers, warranty details, maintenance history, location) alongside the specifics of their maintenance contracts, including Service Level Agreements (SLAs), payment terms, and renewal dates. It ensures all relevant data is easily accessible and organized.
Efficient Work Order Management: Clients can use the CMMS to generate and track maintenance requests and work orders for their contracted service providers. This includes logging new issues, assigning tasks to specific contractors, setting priorities, and monitoring the status of each job in real-time. The system can automate notifications to contractors and provide a clear audit trail of all communications and actions.
Performance Monitoring and SLA Compliance: A CMMS allows clients to rigorously track the performance of their contract maintenance providers against agreed-upon SLAs. They can monitor key metrics such as response times, resolution times, completion rates, and adherence to scheduled preventive maintenance. Reporting features within the CMMS provide data-driven insights into contractor effectiveness, enabling informed decisions about contract renewals or adjustments.
Cost Control and Budgeting: By centralizing maintenance data, clients can gain a clear overview of expenditures related to contract maintenance. The CMMS helps track costs associated with specific work orders, assets, and contractors. This data is crucial for budgeting, identifying areas for cost optimization, and verifying invoices from service providers against actual work performed.
Historical Data and Analytics: The system compiles a comprehensive history of all maintenance activities, providing a detailed record of all maintenance events. This historical data is invaluable for identifying recurring issues, understanding asset lifespan, predicting future maintenance needs, and making strategic decisions about asset replacement or repair versus outsourcing. Analytics tools can highlight trends and potential areas for improvement.

Summary of Contract Maintenance and CMMS

Contract maintenance presents a compelling alternative to in-house teams for many companies. Primarily driven by the desire to reduce specialized knowledge requirements and cut costs. However, this approach introduces its administrative complexities, particularly in drafting comprehensive maintenance agreements.

Maintenance Contract aims for ambitious service improvements, necessitating substantial investments and blending elements of performance-based and design-bid-build approaches. A Computerized Maintenance Management System (CMMS) is highlighted as a critical tool for optimizing contract maintenance. Benefiting both the client and the service provider. For clients who are outsourcing maintenance. Ultimately, a CMMS transforms contract maintenance into a more transparent process.

Paweł Bęś

Paweł Bęś, Logistics and Maintenance Marketing Expert for QRmaint. He is a B2B marketer with 8 years of experience in the logistics industry in the Netherlands. His work included business analysis of distribution and supply chain operations of high-tech companies in EMEA and APAC. He was responsible for directing, coordinating, planning and supervising transportation tasks and internal operations. He is currently responsible for marketing activities at QRmaint, a company that provides CMMS systems for various industries.

TPM and RCM: Whirled Class

When a piece of production machinery broke down at the Whirlpool plant in Findlay, Ohio, several years back, it was accepted practice for the machine operator to call maintenance and then sit back and wait for the problem to be fixed. Critical information and knowledge was not shared between the operator and maintenance technician. Like many companies, these workers were stuck in traditional roles - operators run the machines, maintenance fixes the machines, and the two do not cross. As a result, productivity opportunities were missed.

Breaking Tech Barriers to Excel in a Competitive FM Arena

Traditionally, the cost factor was the north star metric for facilities management companies (FMs). However, organizations began to recognize the significant business value and insight the efficient management of their facilities could represent for their operations, with technology as an enabler for this paradigm shift.

TPM Concept and Implementation Approach

Total Productive Maintenance (TPM) is a maintenance program which involves a newly defined concept for maintaining plants and equipment. This paper will define TPM history, benefits, strengths as a maintenance philosophy, its implementation approach, difficulties in its implementation and cost of implementing TPM. TPM is to Maintenance as Total Quality is to Production The goal of the TPM program is to markedly increase production while, at the same time, increasing employee morale and job satisfaction.

The ‘Maintenance Crisis’ and Innovations that are Changing it

A couple months ago, I wrote an article about the top five careers in facility management. I interviewed a broad range of professionals for that story. But it was during an interview with Joel Leonard, President of SkillTV, that I started to ponder what he referred to as “the maintenance crisis”–a depletion of skilled workers in the maintenance management workforce caused by baby boomers retiring and too few young professionals entering the field.

The Danger of the Reduction of Workforce

When a forced layoff takes place in a unionized environment, the latest employees, in this case the apprentices were laid off; the plant had to lay off its future employees. Even sadder is that only four months after the lay offs the plant had to hire back many of the people they laid off. Many of them worked for a contractor who had contracted them to the plant after they were laid off! Soon this plant will start talking about a new improvement initiative and new management will wonder why it is so difficult to get people committed to improvement initiatives.

Contractor Management Controls

Circular logic is how many large, otherwise sophisticated manufacturing plants manage financial accountability over their industrial contractors. They create a PO, send it to the contractor, the contract performs the work, keeps track of expenses, and then submits an invoice. The planning and scheduling and execution of the works are excellent, but the financial control needs upgrading.

Proactive Approach to Shutdowns Reduces Potlatch Maintenance Costs

Effective shutdown management is critical to the operation of mills, for without well-planned and executed shutdowns, equipment reliability suffers, and the mill pays the price in poor quality and lost production. Becoming proficient at managing shutdowns is a way to reduce overall downtime costs so that shutdowns themselves do not consume the savings they are capable of generating.

The Contract Maintenance Conundrum: Balancing Expertise and Cost