Design for Reliability: Facility Upgrades

Design for Reliability: Facility Upgrades

Elizabeth Ruiz

Published on 9/6/2023

This year we are seeing big changes in industrial manufacturing due to new advances in technology and automation, and we are all trying to keep up. Many companies are investing in large-scale facility upgrades to incorporate these new technologies and keep up with demand. From their experiences, we are learning about benefits, challenges, and effects on processes that facility upgrades can bring. A focus on designing for reliability will be essential in planning these upgrades. 

Benefits of Facility Upgrades

Upgrading and automation of equipment and facilities can be beneficial to organizations in many ways. Reliable Plant provides a good list:

Plant Reliability – Replacing older assets with up-to-date equipment eliminates the expensive breakdowns and downtime that problems in older equipment can cause. Improved reliability results in increased manufacturing throughput, lower manufacturing cost, and lower energy consumption. 

System Safety – Modern equipment includes features that ensure that your crew is working safely. 

Cost Savings – Upgrading will incur large costs up front, but the long-term benefits shouldn’t be ignored. Use Life Cycle Cost to financially evaluate the level of reliability we design into the equipment. 

Availability of Parts – Updated equipment has greater spare parts availability than older assets. This makes repairs more affordable and minimizes equipment downtime. Read about how 3D printed spares are changing spare parts procurement.

Digital Capabilities – Use of newer technology in reliability and maintenance, such as Cloud-based applications, IoT connectivity, and condition monitoring sensors provides plant managers’ decision making capabilities by providing actionable equipment information to avoid unplanned downtime.

Challenges of Facility Upgrades

While the benefits to facility upgrades are undeniable, upgrade, expansion, and automation all come with their set of challenges, according to The International Society of Automation. 

Common challenges include: 

• Tendency to go over CapEx and OpEx budgets.
• Underestimation of true cost of delayed startup.
• Overestimation of production levels to be delivered from new capabilities in production.
• Delays in schedule increase CapEx cost and cause delays in expected revenue from new capabilities in production.

Common mistakes made during the facility upgrade process include:

• Lack of project planning knowledge
• Starting the project planning process too late
• Inadequate resources – not enough personnel 
• Inexperience – you have to have the right people 
• Lack of project management oversight – people have to be able to recognize developing problems

Design for Reliability

Many factors should be taken into consideration when upgrading a facility, including preventive maintenance, spare parts management, maintainability, energy conservation, and crew safety. The challenges that facility upgrades and expansions can pose, as well as the extremely high investment value, underline the importance of project planning and designing for reliability, inspectability and maintainability.

Inspectability – Design in a way that equipment can be easily inspected. Inspections allow for planning and scheduling to be done safely, efficiently, and with top quality. Ignoring the importance of inspectability during the design phase will create an environment of reactive maintenance. 

Maintainability – Design in a way that assets can be easily maintained. For example, pumps, motors, and other components that need to be repaired or replaced need to be safely and easily accessible to the maintenance crew. 

Reliability – Designing for reliability mitigates future reliability and maintenance problems during the design phase. Designing for reliability can improve OPE (increasing equipment availability, reducing loss, increasing time between failures, and decreasing time to repair).

Other planning steps that are helpful in facility upgrades include needs assessments, budget planning, process transition, how progress will be measured, how those measurements are used for improvement, and facility design. 

Conclusion

Facility upgrades offer a range of benefits, including improved plant reliability, enhanced safety, long-term cost savings, and the integration of digital capabilities. Nonetheless, challenges like budget overruns and production overestimations must be managed. Designing for reliability, inspectability, and maintainability is paramount, ensuring sustained performance, minimal downtime, and cost avoidance. 

Midweek with Maintenance World

Looking for a midweek break? Keep up with the latest news brought to you every Wednesday by the Maintenance World crew.

Related Articles

Cardinal Manufacturing, Helping to Bridge the Manufacturing Skills Gap

The manufacturing industry is a crucial contributor to the economy, accounting for over 11% of the total output in the United States. However, many manufacturing companies are currently facing a skills gap, with more open job positions than there are workers ready to fill them. A study conducted by Deloitte and the Manufacturing Institute predicts that 2.1 million manufacturing positions will go unfilled by 2030, potentially leading to a loss of $1 trillion in GDP for the United States.

The manufacturing industry is a crucial contributor to the economy, accounting for over 11% of the total output in the United States. However, many manufacturing companies are currently facing a skills gap, with more open job positions than there are workers ready to fill them. A study conducted by Deloitte and the Manufacturing Institute predicts that 2.1 million manufacturing positions will go unfilled by 2030, potentially leading to a loss of $1 trillion in GDP for the United States.

See More

South Carolina Ranked as the #1 State for Manufacturing

Manufacturing has been a key component to the South Carolina economy in the last 10 years and the state's efforts to improve infrastructure and educate a highly skilled workforce are paying off. The state has been making headlines lately for its attractiveness to corporations around the world. 

Manufacturing has been a key component to the South Carolina economy in the last 10 years and the state's efforts to improve infrastructure and educate a highly skilled workforce are paying off. The state has been making headlines lately for its attractiveness to corporations around the world. 

See More

The Decade of American Reshoring

The COVID-19 pandemic and recent world events have pushed manufacturing companies to shift their production to the United States in 2023, with 1,8000 companies in the US alone planning to reshore production to the states. While reshoring efforts are ramping up, manufacturers must be wary of the skills gap.

The COVID-19 pandemic and recent world events have pushed manufacturing companies to shift their production to the United States in 2023, with 1,8000 companies in the US alone planning to reshore production to the states. While reshoring efforts are ramping up, manufacturers must be wary of the skills gap.

See More

Lost Radioactive Capsule Proves Preventive Maintenance is as Important as Ever

Preventive Maintenance is as important as ever and this is extremely evident considering a radioactive capsule was lost in the vast landscape of Western Australia for nearly 2 weeks. Emergency services had been scanning the truck’s route for the last seven days and finally found the capsule on Wednesday, February 1st. A team driving down the road used radiation detection equipment to locate the capsule on the side of the road, outside of Newman.

Preventive Maintenance is as important as ever and this is extremely evident considering a radioactive capsule was lost in the vast landscape of Western Australia for nearly 2 weeks. Emergency services had been scanning the truck’s route for the last seven days and finally found the capsule on Wednesday, February 1st. A team driving down the road used radiation detection equipment to locate the capsule on the side of the road, outside of Newman.

See More

HBD Condition Monitoring Devices at the center of Ohio Derailment

It appears the three rail workers on board the train took the appropriate measure when the sensor alerted them a bearing/axel was too hot. However, upon conducting further research it appears the system of HBDs in North America are largely ineffective.

It appears the three rail workers on board the train took the appropriate measure when the sensor alerted them a bearing/axel was too hot. However, upon conducting further research it appears the system of HBDs in North America are largely ineffective.

See More

Failure Analysis Uncovers the Cause of the Keystone Oil Spill

After nearly 2 months of investigations and a root cause analysis, TC Energy Corp revealed the cause of the oil spill was likely a combination of a welding flaw and bending stress fatigue which resulted in a crack forming and eventually lead to the rupture. The cause of the bending stress is still unclear and remains a focal point of the root cause failure analysis a third-party is conducting.  

After nearly 2 months of investigations and a root cause analysis, TC Energy Corp revealed the cause of the oil spill was likely a combination of a welding flaw and bending stress fatigue which resulted in a crack forming and eventually lead to the rupture. The cause of the bending stress is still unclear and remains a focal point of the root cause failure analysis a third-party is conducting.  

See More

Ohio Foundry Explosion

On February 20th around 2pm an explosion erupted at the I. Schumann & Co. Foundry in Bedford, Ohio. The foundry recycles scrap metal into bronze and brass ingots and pellets. Fire officials say the cause of the explosion is under investigation by state and federal authorities but it appears the blast originated near a kettle-like piece of equipment which holds molten metals before being poured into molds.

On February 20th around 2pm an explosion erupted at the I. Schumann & Co. Foundry in Bedford, Ohio. The foundry recycles scrap metal into bronze and brass ingots and pellets. Fire officials say the cause of the explosion is under investigation by state and federal authorities but it appears the blast originated near a kettle-like piece of equipment which holds molten metals before being poured into molds.

See More